Case Study 4.1 (M) Paper on Designing and Implementing GIS Unit within ANY organization of your choice.
“Design and Implementation of GIS Technology” within any fictional or real agency, as School, University, Environmental Agency,
It is recommended to contact a GIS practitioner – GIS Manager or GIS professional involved in running GIS facility. LECTURE 4.
Fuzzy Sets & Fuzzy
David O’Sullivan, David Unwin
Analysis”, chapter 11, pp. 316-356
Peter Burrough, Rachael
McDonnell “Principles of GIS”,
chapter 11, pp. 265 – 297
Fuzzy Sets & Fuzzy
Imprecision as a way of thought.
Operations on several fuzzy sets
boundaries & fuzzy attributes
Advantages & Disadvantages
Application of fuzzy classification
To model geographical phenomena – first necessary to
divide the world either into CRISP ENTITIES or into
These fundamental spatial entities
– points, lines, polygons, pixels – are described by their:
All these statements in conventional logic can have only 2
values: TRUE & FALSE: 0 & 1.
The principles of 2-valued logic.
Lies at the heart of most of mathematics & computer
Many geographical phenomena are not simple clear-cut entities.
The patterns vary over many spatial and temporal scales.
Defined by many interacting attributes.
Until recently we had no means in GIS, apart from statistics,
for dealing with entities that are not crispy defined.
By limiting the rules of logic to binary decisions we limit the
retrieval and classification of data to situations in which
ONLY A COMPLETE MATCH is possible.
In real life we make compromises based on the DEGREE
with which an object meets our specifications.
E.g. House. Rock types, soil/vegetation classes, socio-economic
groupings, decisions in law courts (guilty, not, or not proven),
nationality, even the borders of the nation state
The Law of the EXCLUDED middle and its role in
mathematical proof – of paramount importance in scientific
& philosophical development.
The rules of logic used in PC query languages are based on
EXACT ideas of truth or falsehood.
In environmental data this is not necessarily so…
“He says that he always lies” Neither true nor false. It is a
Many users of Geo Info have a clear notion of what they need.
Land users & evaluators.
Imprecisely formulated requests (which areas are under the threat
Must be translated in terms of the basic units of information
available. Not all information is EXACT !!!
Geo phenomena are more complicated.
We must consider grouping both in ATTRIBUTE (whether
all entities are of the same kind) & GEOGRAPHIC
space(whether entities of the same kind occupy a
Very often we ‘ve concentrated only on building class
definitions from attributes with assumption that similar
entities will cluster together…
This may be the case, BUT…
How to deal with imprecision in overlapping attribute
Fuzzy Sets &
Conventional or crisp sets allow ONLY binary membership
functions (T or F). CRISP BOOLEAN SETS.
An individual IS or IS NOT a member of any set. All
members match the class concept, the class boundaries
Fuzzy sets admits the possibility of partial membership.
The class boundaries are NOT or CANNOT be SHARPLY defined.
• Boolean CRISP Set. FUZZY Set.
Fuzzy Sets &
In Fuzzy sets the grade of membership is expressed in terms of a
scale that can vary CONTINUOUSLY between 0 & 1.
Individuals to different degrees can be members of more
than one set…
THE BOUNDARY VALUES based on attributes.
In CRISP sets: – on the basis of expert knowledge; – using
methods of numerical taxonomy.
Both options are possible with FUZZY sets.
1. Uses a priori membership function with which individuals
can be assigned a membership grade.
The Semantic Import Approach or Model SI
2. The value of the membership function is a function of the
classifier used. METHOD of FUZZY K-MEANS
1. THE SEMANTIC IMPORT APPROACH – SI
Useful in situations where users have a very good,
QUALITATIVE IDEA of how to group data,
but for various reasons – difficulties with exactness.
The membership function should ensure that the GRADE of
membership is 1.00 at the center of the set, that it falls off
through the fuzzy boundaries to the regions outside the set,
where it takes the value 0.
The SI approach to polygon boundaries.
You can incorporate information about the nature
of the boundaries and also to calculate sensible
2 separate approaches: the map-unit, and the
individual boundary approach.
The SI approach can be used to add information
about the abruptness of boundaries to a polygon
Picture of spatial variation across and along
2. FUZZY K-MEANS.
Very often users may not know which classification is
useful and appropriate.
Soil science, geohydrology, vegetation mapping.
Translating a multiple attribute description of an
object into k membership values to k classes or
Rainforest types, heavy metal pollution.
SI approach to exactly delineated polygons can
improve their information content, providing
information about the nature of the sharpness or
diffuseness of the identified boundaries.
Results are more congruent with reality.
Membership values can be easily interpolated
THE GREATEST DIFFICULTIES come with
choosing the values of the control parameters to
obtain the best results: the kind of membership
functions, boundary values, transition widths, etc.
In situations where a well-defined and functional
scheme – SI APPROACH.
SI continuous classes are more robust and less
prone to errors and extremes than simple Boolean
classes that use the same attribute boundaries.
Fuzzy k-means approach is appropriate when
information about the number and definition of
classes is lacking.
Fuzzy k-means methods yield sets of optimal,
overlapping classes that can be also mapped in
data space and in geographical space.